Bank error led to child withdrawing $3000

Home Guides & cases Case notes Bank accounts - 10388

Bank error led to child withdrawing $3000

Categories:

Children's accounts

Summary:

Hana and Tony wanted to open an account for their 14-year-old son, and told the bank they wanted to limit the amount he could withdraw from it. The bank said a trust account would best suit their needs. The account's terms and conditions clearly stated that a parent or guardian of any child under 15 had to sign all deposit and withdrawal slips unless the parent or guardian gave the bank an indemnity allowing the child to access the account. On the basis of this information, Hana and Tony opened a trust account without providing an indemnity.

As a result of a bank error, their son was later able to withdraw $3,000 without authorisation from either parent or a designated guardian. Hana and Tony complained to the bank, which offered compensation of $250. They did not accept the offer, considering it unrealistic and an insult, and complained to us.

Our investigation

They accepted that their son was partially responsible for the withdrawal, but considered the bank was also at fault by failing to set up the account in accordance with the applicable terms and conditions. After we discussed the case with the bank, it offered $1,500, half of the loss suffered.

Outcome

Hana and Tony accepted the offer.

Print this page

Relevant Case Notes

Chargebacks

Chargeback rights applicable following fraudulent card use

Sophia was staying with a friend when her friend’s son took her credit card from her handbag, wrote down the details and returned the card unseen. He subsequent...

Read full case note

Kiwisaver

Evidence lacking for claim that bank mis-sold KiwiSaver

When Matthew was in his early 50s, he received a $500,000 redundancy pay-out. He invested $50,000 of it in an online savings account and $200,000 in a regular s...

Read full case note

Mobile banking

Bank and customer both played part in $45,000 loss

Tama had personal, company and family trust bank accounts, all of which he could access through internet banking. Tama lent money to his son-in-law Ray to buy a...

Read full case note